Subsequent to yesterday’s post, the DOF has published building level property tax statements for the affected co-op buildings. This allows for a detailed breakdown of the non-primary residence surcharge data.
I have also reached out to the DOF’s press office for comment on the extra-statutory tax ramps (phase-ins) for properties just above key thresholds, first reported here. A discussion with former NYC Finance Commissioner Martha Stark1 has increased my confidence that this treatment is contrary to the law. I’ll update with any response the DOF provides.
Highlights
7,489 homes were billed for $563 million
Manhattan property owners were billed 93% of the total dollars
Condos are responsible for 57%, houses 26%, and co-ops 17%
The median bill for houses and condo units was $56,900
574 homes’ bills were reduced by a total of $11.83 million due to the phase-ins
Maps & Tables
Methodological Notes
The BBL level charges were obtained by scraping the Account History Details from the DOF’s property information site. Co-op unit counts were scraped from the PDF quarterly tax statements dated November 14th.2
Bill reductions due to the rate phase-ins at key thresholds were obtained directly from the tax information for condos and 1-3 family homes, while for co-op units they were inferred based on their total charges, total affected units, and unit level valuations from the supplemental roll.
Raw Data
Stark has provided an expert affirmation for the plaintiffs in the pied-a-terre tax procedural lawsuit as well as expert affidavits for the plaintiffs in the Tax Equity Now NY property tax reform litigation.
The quarterly tax statements were originally posted with a table of charges at the individual unit level. The DOF has since re-posted them with only the aggregate number of affected units.





